Jays Fight Back in 98th Meeting of Jesuit – Holy Cross
Despite the 31-17 loss to Holy Cross, the Jesuit football team proved they still had a lot of fight in an inspiring third quarter surge.

Junior Noah Varnado makes an athletic reception along the sideline at the end of the second quarter against Holy Cross. The play lit a fire under the Jesuit offense that carried over into the second half.
The 98th meeting of Jesuit and Holy Cross in the Great American Rivalry Series was an encounter both strange and hopeful for the Jesuit Blue Jays.
View the Photo Gallery from the Jesuit vs. Holy Cross Game
View the Photo Gallery from the Rivalry Tailgate and Parade
The 31-7 loss to the Tigers was strange because it seemed like two different football games were played under the lights at Tad Gormely Stadium, separated by the 4:00 mark in the second quarter. For the first 20 minutes of play, Holy Cross was stunningly dominant, amassing 31 points by scoring every time they touched the ball. The Tigers were poised to reverse the fate of last year’s Jesuit shutout victory and paced even to double the 38-point game score differential.
The Blue Jays, conversely, were foiled at every turn. As the clock ticked down to 4:10 in the second quarter and Holy Cross had just completed a 93-yard drive to improve their lead to 31-0, something had to give. A break had to come.
That break did come as senior quarterback Alex Watermeier scrambled out of the pocket toward the Jesuit sideline and threw a laser-precise rocket into the hands of junior receiver Noah Varnado. Varnado managed to scrape a foot in bounds and hang onto the contested ball for a massive 41-yard reception. That one play nearly doubled Jesuit’s total offensive yardage to that point in the game.

Senior Michael Torry crosses the goal line to give the Jays life at the end of the second quarter. The 4-yard touchdown run made the score 31-7.
A defensive pass interference penalty on an end zone attempt to senior tight end Drew Black set up four-yard touchdown scramble by senior running back Michael Torry.
Time ran out on the final Holy Cross drive of the half, and so both the offense and the defense left the field at halftime having tasted their first successful campaign on each side of the ball – bleak maybe, but important. The score at the break was 31-7.
“I believe that our guys came out ready to play from the start,” said head football coach Mark Songy. “Holy Cross turned some big plays on us early, and we found ourselves in big hole. At halftime, I told the players that the second half would show us what kind of character we have – whether or not we face the second half believing we could win this football game.”
What made the game so strange was that the tides reversed almost completely for the Tigers and the Jays at the end of the second quarter. The Jesuit defense played an inspired second half of football; so much so that, excepting a dead ball foul penalty, Holy Cross did not earn a single first down after halftime and were limited to less than 50 second-half yards of offense.
“We really shut them down in the second half” added Songy. “Honestly, Holy Cross is a really talented team and have some really skilled players. I was very proud of our guys, that we fought as hard as we did in the second half. It’s always a plus to come out of a test of character like this knowing that you’re a tough football team.”
The defense was also responsible for the second momentum driving play of the game when junior safety Wyatt Candies hauled in his first interception of the season on the Holy Cross 35 yard line. The excellent field position eventually set up a 7-yard touchdown pass from Watermeier to junior receiver Brenden Berggren, making the score 31-14 with 2:45 left in the third quarter.
The next drive for Jesuit started after a Holy Cross punt had pinned the Jays on their own eight yard line. Building momentum with each play, Watermeier connected first on the back shoulder of Noah Varnado for 31 yards, then on the opposite side of the field to junior receiver Robert McMahon for another 19. The drive eventually led to a field goal and a narrowed deficit of 31-17 with 10:24 left to play.
That moment in the game stands out as one of clear hope for the Blue Jay football team in the 2017 football season. With a record now of 1-4 on the season, the fighting Blue Jays had picked themselves up after taking a stunning first-half punch from Holy Cross. To get within two scores and have a shot at victory seemed impossible in the first half. And yet the Jesuit football team found itself in this position.
Although the Holy Cross defense was able to hold back Jesuit’s fourth quarter attack, Jesuit has much to be proud of in preserving the aggressive Blue Jay spirit and battling their way back into the fight. This is the why there will never be a dull moment in the oldest rivalry in the city, a rivalry that will long endure as a testament to the rich legacy each school carries on in the city of New Orleans.
The Blue Jays have a week to prepare for their next challenge of the season, facing the John Curtis Patriots next Friday night at the Shrine on Airline. Kickoff is set for 7:00 PM.
Read More…
The Advocate – Huge first half enough for Holy Cross in win over Jesuit
Galleries
Week 5 Rivalry Game: Jesuit (17) vs. Holy Cross (31), Tad Gormley, Sept. 29, 2017
-
Future Jays have a blast with Jesuit's mascot, Jayson, in the stands.
-
Fr. Paul Shaughnessy, S.J., Fr. John Brown, S.J., Fr. Christopher Fronk, S.J., and Fr. Kevin Dyer, S.J..
-
The Great American Rivalry coin toss
-
Principal Peter Kernion '90 accepts the Scholar Athlete award on behalf of senior defensive lineman Matt Frischhertz.
-
The seniors get the crowd pumped before the big game.
-
Jesuit's cheerleaders kept the crowd enthusiastic throughout.
-
The coveted Golden Football remains with the winning team for a year after the rivalry matchup.
-
Legend of the game Rick Chanove '89 received his award from Marine Staff Sergeant Michael McKarry.
-
Jesuit's service director, Kevin Murphy, accepts a community service award on behalf of senior Michael Hull.
-
Jesuit cheerleaders hold up the "Eat the Tigers" banner, while the football players bunch together before they...
-
...tear the banner open and take the field!
-
The team stands for the presentation of the colors and the singing of the national anthem.
-
Jesuit's MCJROTC presented the colors before the National Anthem.
-
The MCJROTC presents the colors.
-
Staff Sergeant Michael McKarry presented the 2017 Distinguished Military Alumnus, Captain Ronald Drez, with his award.
-
The Blue Jay student section, also known as The Gizzard, gets ready for the opening kickoff.
-
Lined up in shotgun, Watermeier hands it off to junior tailback Willie Robinson.
-
Brenden Berggren shakes off a Tiger defender at the sideline and adds a few extra yards on this punt return.
-
Junior defensive lineman Matthew Sauviac (48) closes in on the Tiger tailback, forcing him towards the sideline and other Blue Jay defenders Marquis Martin (99) and Perri Ganci (98).
-
The "D-line," coached by defensive coordinator Troy Baglio, huddles up during a timeout.
-
Defensive lineman Perri Ganci glances over at the Jesuit bench for the signal from Coach Baglio.
-
Safety Cameron Helm follows behind cornerback Ethan Kerrigan, who makes a nice hit on the Holy Cross ball carrier.
-
After Holy Cross scores its second touchdown, the Blue Jay defensive linemen pinch together in an attempt to block the point after.
-
Seniors in the Gizzard "go insane" in front of the WGNO camera man.
-
The four quadrants: the Jayettes, Blue Jay Band, cheerleaders, and the Gizzard.
-
Tight end Anthony Cibilich takes a break with offensive linemen Will Shropshire and Cooper Arnold to discuss blocking assignments with coach Zac Creel '13
-
Bro. Terry Todd '58 went full-on Braveheart for the game.
-
Middle linebacker Roman Bankson eyes down the Tigers' quarterback.
-
Defensive linemen Marquis Martin and Perri Ganci tackle the opposing tailback for a loss.
-
Punter/kicker Max Scheurich sends the ball into opposing territory in the second half.
-
The Gizzard goes wild after a big play.
-
With a sea of Blue Jay defenders crashing in to help him, Roman Bankson records the solo tackle by catching the Holy Cross running back at his shoelaces.
-
Senior Matt Alexander, running back and return specialist, reads the punter's eyes as he begins to move toward the sideline to make the fair catch.
-
Receivers Drew Black (#87) and Robert McMahon (#15) check on teammate Marc Dougherty as he is helped off the field by Jesuit trainers.
-
SIDELINE GRAB: Robert McMahon hauls in Watermeier's pass and keeps a foot in along the sideline for a big gain.
-
Band director Mr. Joe Caluda leads the Blue Jay Band in the Jesuit Alma Mater.
-
Fr. Kevin Dyer, S.J., Jesuit's chaplain, and Fr. John Brown, S.J., the superior of the Jesuits and major gift officer for the Office of Institutional Advancement
-
Down 14 points, running back Michael Torry finds some open field with six minutes remaining in the game.
-
Despite the setbacks of the football game, spirits remained high all evening.
-
Torry follows fullback Perri Ganci, who primarily plays defensive end, past the first wave of Tiger defenders.
-
The offensive line sets up a counter play for senior back Michael Torry.
-
Quarterback Alex Watermeier hits the open receiver on an out route.
-
Watermeier lines up in shotgun formation with Torry alongside him.
-
Every year, the Great American Rivalry Series holds a chin-up contest between the two competing schools. Here, Marine Staff Sergeant Michael McKarry presented the Jesuit cheerleaders with the official trophy after they completed over 1500 chin-ups.
-
The 98th anniversary of the Great American Rivalry between Jesuit and Holy Cross ended with the final score in the Tigers' favor, 31-17.
-
Athletic director Steve Costa of Holy Cross receives the Golden Football from Jesuit's athletic director, Dave Moreau.
-
Alumni directors Mat Grau '68 (Jesuit) and Charles Illanne (Holy Cross) share a laugh on the field after the game.
-
Seniors Matthew Frischhertz (left) and Michael Hull both won awards for scholarship and community service, respectively.